There are many different stories of the Revolutionary
War. Many people have written their own
version of what happened, with each one having different plots and characters.
However, the more you look into it, many stories do in fact have the same
general idea. The movie The Patriot and the book The Fighting Ground are
very similar, yet also have their fair share of differences.
Both of the tales told make the authors interpretation of
what they think happened in the war come alive. In the book The Fighting
Ground, Jonathan would do anything to be able to fight in the war, but
being only 13 years old, his parents tell him that it is not safe, and he is
not old enough to do so. In the movie The Patriot, Gabriel is completely
convinced that he will fight in the war, because his father was a war commander
in the past. However, Gabriel’s dreams get crushed when his father tells him
that there is no chance that he will fight, because he does not want to loose
his son. Both stories have a character who wants to fight, yet is held back by
their parents.
Not only do both characters want to fight in the war, both
end up going behind their parents back, and sneakily sign up to fight. Jonathan realizes that if he wants to fight,
he will have to run away and sign up for the war himself. Gabriel’s story goes
a little differently. He is 17 and can sign up no problem if he wanted to,
however he had to make the heartbreaking decision to either follow his heart,
or follow his dad. No matter how you look at it, both boys in the end go
against their parents’ wishes and decide for themselves that fighting would be
the best decision.
After signing up, the only thing left for both boys to do is
fight. However, being young can cause problems in war. Inexperienced fighters
are more likely to get killed or captured. And for both boys, getting captured
was the case. Thinking he was being spied on by the Hessians, Jonathan was
taken by the British, and held hostage. Gabriel was captured by the British and
being taken with them. Both boys eventually found strength, and got out of this
situation, yet the both were captured. The boys both were too young to be in
the war, and both of their lives were risked.
I would argue that the book and movie are very similar, or
at least these two characters are very similar. Yet, if we look at how the
books end, you will see that the boys journeys end differently. Jonathan
escapes from the British, and then that’s it. That story is over, however the
movie goes on a little more. Gabriel still decides to fight, even after being
taken, and in the end Gabriel gets killed. Though both tales seem so similar,
they still end differently.
The Revolutionary War was a very hard, yet victorious time
for our country. Families went through different troubles and hardships, with
no two exactly the same. However I think that The Patriot and The
Fighting Ground are two very similar stories that show how families do
fight, and kids do rebel against their parents, because if you really want to
fight – you will find a way.